Can a Public College Be Sued for an Inaccessible Website?
A federal appeals court restored two students' awards for lost educational opportunities at a Los Angeles college, and upheld an order that the college district verify its vendors' accessibility claims itself.
Rick Hensbergen5 minute read
A student who is blind tries to register for a class, apply for financial aid, and keep up with what is happening on campus, and the college's websites make each of those hard. One student told a federal jury exactly that about Los Angeles City College. On March 11, 2026, a federal appeals court restored the damages the jury awarded him and a second student, and upheld an order that the college district check its vendors' accessibility claims for itself.
The case
Roy Payan and Portia Mason enrolled at Los Angeles City College, a campus of the Los Angeles Community College District, in 2015. Both use JAWS, screen-reading software that reads electronic text aloud. In March 2017, with the National Federation of the Blind, they sued the district under Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act. The appeal is Payan v. Los Angeles Community College District (opens in a new tab), No. 24-1809, in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit.
At the second trial, the appeals court records, "Payan testified that the LACC and LACCD websites were inaccessible, making it difficult for him to register for courses, apply for financial aid, or stay abreast of the goings-on of campus." The jury found the district liable on fourteen of nineteen factual allegations, and found intentional violations of Title II on nine. Those included "the accessibility issues pertaining to the websites," along with library resources, classroom software, and textbooks.
What the awards pay for
The jury awarded $218,500 to Payan and $24,000 to Mason. The trial court cut the awards, reasoning that they "could only be attributed to one of two impermissible sources: emotional damages or lost educational opportunities."
The Ninth Circuit pulled those two apart. On emotional distress, it agreed with the trial court: "we hold that emotional distress damages are not available under Title II of the ADA." On lost opportunities, it disagreed: "We agree that plaintiffs may seek compensatory damages for lost educational opportunities under Title II of the ADA."
The students had presented evidence, the court wrote, that they lost opportunities "to meaningfully learn class material, engage in classroom discussions, and explore their educational interests." Holding that the trial court "abused its discretion in granting remittitur," it sent the case back "with instructions to reinstate the jury's damages award of $218,500 to Payan and $24,000 to Mason." Judge Lee dissented in part, writing that "the jury in reality compensated the plaintiffs for impermissible emotional distress." On May 1, 2026, the trial court reinstated both awards.
The order on vendors
The trial court's permanent injunction, entered February 29, 2024, runs for three years. Within three months, the district had to make its own website, the college's website, and "other educational or instructional websites available to students enrolled at LACC" compliant with WCAG 2.1 Level AA. The court heard testimony that the district had itself asked for its new websites to meet 2.1, and that "WCAG 2.1 AA is the industry standard."
Before buying software, the district already collected a Voluntary Product Accessibility Template, a form "prepared by the software developer" about its own product, and sent it to an outside accessibility consultant. The court called that process "a satisfactory safeguard," then recorded testimony "that in his experience VPATs tend to be unreliable and that the reliability of third-party consultants varies significantly depending on the consultant."
The injunction's answer was direct. When the district uses outside vendors to assess accessibility, it "shall periodically, independently verify the reliability of the third-party vendor's certifications." The Ninth Circuit affirmed the injunction (opens in a new tab) the same day, in a separate memorandum.
What this means for your own organization
The barriers in this case sat in the tasks a student came to do: registering, applying for aid, doing coursework. The order on vendors puts a plain idea into a court's words. The obligation stays with the organization, whatever its vendor promised, and a vendor's description of its own product is something to verify.
Verification needs a record: what was found, when, and what has been resolved since, kept by someone other than the vendor. Esther assesses a site and dates every finding, so a supplier's claim can be set against what people actually run into on the page.
- Can a person using a screen reader register, apply, or pay on your site from start to finish?
- When a vendor says its product is accessible, who has checked that claim, and when?
- Could your organization show, with dates, what was found and what has been fixed since?
How this applies to a particular organization is a question for its counsel. For public colleges and other public bodies, what Title II asks is set out at For government, and for private organizations, at For business.
Sources: the Ninth Circuit's published opinion and its memorandum disposition of March 11, 2026, in Payan v. Los Angeles Community College District, No. 24-1809; and the Permanent Injunction (Document 612) and Order Regarding Final Injunction (Document 613) of February 29, 2024, and the order of May 1, 2026 (Document 651), in No. 2:17-cv-01697, U.S. District Court for the Central District of California. Read November 4, 2026.
About the author

Rick Hensbergen is the founder and CEO of Esther. He has spent his career in governance and risk, twenty years of it at major banks in the United States and the United Kingdom, including as a Senior Manager approved by the UK's Financial Conduct Authority.
